How to Negotiate a Car Accident Insurance Claim

negotiating car claim payout

car insurance claim payoutWhether you are dealing with USAA, Farmers, State Farm, Nation Wide, GEICO, Progressive or one of the many other auto insurance companies for your totaled car, they all have the same objective... to reduce auto claim costs as much as possible.

Auto insurance adjusters that work for these companies are highly trained negotiators.

Their primary job is to:

  1. Establish rapport and build relationship with you (it is easier to settle when you are best of buddies)
  2. Gain your cooperation (they know you want to settle your claim as soon as possible and they use this to their advantage)
  3. Get your agreement to the facts (the facts as they see them... these facts benefit the insurance company not you)
  4. Lead you step by step through their "claim settlement process" (that's right, they have a claims play book and if you let them run the play successfully... they win... you lose)

How to get the highest car claim payout Learn more here.

Insurance adjusters use this negotiating process to lead you away from your arguments, opinions and YOUR facts (like the value of your car) and towards the "facts of of your car accident claim" as they see them. The facts as they relate to your total loss car claim is getting your agreement to settle at the insurance company's actual cash value appraisal for your car. Which in most all cases (unless they messed up) is lower than what you can actually get paid for your total loss car claim.

The entire process is methodical and structured to get your agreement for the purpose of settling your claim quickly and for the lowest cost to the insurance company. This is revealed in the video below.

The truth is, their "settlement process" works and the result is the insurance company saves money... money they don't have to pay you.
Watch this video to get a better understanding of how insurance adjusters are  trained to get you to settle your claim.

While I understand the insurance companies business case for needing a "settlement process", most people do not have the same level of experience or the tools (your own actual cash value appraisal) to effectively counter the insurance company's low value settlement offer.

The fact is, the insurance companies settlement process is so effective most people I have spoken to actually believe they got a fair car accident claim settlement. These were people who settled their total loss car claim using arguments, classified ads or the blue book.

It is actually very easy to get the insurance company to increase their cash offer by using these methods. Truth is, insurance adjusters expect you to complain, quote the blue book value or some car ads. This is why their initial offer is so low; so they can increase it a bit so you feel like you "won".

In reality they are happy, ready and eager to pay you just a bit more if it means settling the case and saving money paying your claim.

This may be hard to believe or you may think this won't happen in your case, but from my experience, people who did not negotiate their car accident insurance settlement with an actual cash value appraisal... almost everyone of them lost at least $2,000 to more than $7,000 on their insurance claim payout.

Remember, insurance adjusters are trained pros at making your  believe you got a fair deal.


How to get the highest car claim payout Learn more here.


Related Posts

  • 58
    One question many car owners have when in a collision is what makes a car totaled, or what is commonly known as a "total loss" or "write-off". This question can confuse many people especially if they have been in a car accident and their vehicle appears to have sustained minimal…
    Tags: car, insurance, totaled, progressive, farm, state, cash, actual, farmers
  • 57
    The most common response I see quoted online for the question, "what makes a car totaled", is when the cost to repair the damage equals 75% or more of the actual cash value of the car. This is very misleading because this percentage is different in some states. While some…
    Tags: car, insurance, totaled, actual, cash, claim, state, appraisal, farm, geico
  • 50
    Book Value When it comes to getting an accurate picture of what your car is worth, the most common issue that has to be addressed is the actual value of the vehicle. In the auto industry, many turn to a few online tools like the Kelley Blue Book ( and the…
    Tags: car, appraisal, insurance, state, farm, geico, actual, cash

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Facebook Comments:

Leave A Reply (1 comment so far)

  1. Faylinn
    11 months ago

    Yesterday, I got in a car accident and I have never had to negotiate an auto insurance claim before. However, I am really glad that I was able to come across this post as I hadn’t realized that it was possible to get an insurance agency to increase their cash offer. I am definitely going to watch your video on claims negotiation before I call the agency.

Cash Loans

Low Interest Car Loans

Uncover Any Vehicle’s Accident History

Disclaimer: "All brand names and product names used on this website are trade names, service marks, trademarks, or registered trademarks of their respective owners."

Affiliate Disclosure: I am grateful to be able to provide great content free of charge. As part of my content, I do make recommendations to products and services. If you click on one of those links and purchase, I may earn a referral commission in most cases. Your support in purchasing through these links enables me to keep my website operating costs to a minimum . Thank you, in advance for your support!

%d bloggers like this: